Maintaining Respect While Challenging Assumptions

When encountering assumptions that may be outdated, biased, or limiting (sometimes linked to patterns like the Benevolent Sexism Echo), challenging them constructively requires care. This page offers techniques for questioning assumptions while maintaining respect and preserving relationships.

Practical Techniques

Technique 1: Use Curiosity-Based Questions

Frame challenges as inquiries rather than accusations:

“Help me understand the thinking behind that assumption.”
“What experiences have led you to see it that way?”
“I have a different perspective based on [X]. Could we explore that?”
“What if we looked at it from this alternative angle?”

Genuine curiosity invites reflection rather than triggering defensiveness.

Technique 2: Focus on Impact, Not Intent

Address the consequences of the assumption, not the person’s character:

“When we assume [X], it can inadvertently lead to [negative impact].”
“While I know you mean well, assumptions like that can sometimes make [group] feel underestimated.”
“Focusing only on [assumption] might cause us to miss opportunities related to [alternative].”

This approach separates the problematic assumption from the person holding it.

Technique 3: Share Contrasting Evidence or Experiences Gently

Offer alternative data points without directly attacking their view:

“My experience has actually been a bit different. For instance…”
“I recently read an interesting study that showed…”
“In my observation, I’ve seen situations where…”
“Can I share a perspective from someone who experienced this differently?”

Providing alternative evidence allows them to reconsider without feeling personally invalidated.

Why These Approaches Work

These techniques work because they:

Reduce the likelihood of triggering defensive reactions.
Maintain focus on the issue rather than making it a personal attack.
Create space for reflection and potential perspective shifts.
Preserve relationship quality even when addressing sensitive topics.

Choose Your Battles Wisely

Not every assumption needs to be challenged, especially minor ones in low-stakes situations. Prioritize challenging assumptions that have significant negative impacts or perpetuate harmful stereotypes. Assess the relationship and context before deciding how and when to engage.

Additional Considerations

Timing and setting are crucial; choose private, calm moments for these conversations.
Use “I” statements to own your perspective (“I see it differently” vs. “You’re wrong”).
Acknowledge any shared values or goals before addressing the problematic assumption.
Be prepared for the possibility that the assumption may not change immediately; focus on planting seeds for thought.

50Guide